BankTrack calls upon banks to Close the Gap on investment policies

New report evaluates quality of investment policies of 49 banks; more policies in place, overall quality below what is required
Main
Banks
By BankTrack | Nijmegen, the Netherlands, Apr 27 2010

BankTrack, the international NGO network monitoring the banking sector, today presents Close the Gap, an extensive research project on the quality of lending and investment policies of major international banks [1]. The results are available as a report and online website section.

The aim of the research project was to evaluate to what extent banks have incorporated sustainability criteria into their lending and investment policies. To assess the quality of policies, BankTrack has evaluated the policies of 49 banks from 17 countries for seven key business sectors and on nine sustainability issues.[2] In addition, the project reviews the performance of banks on transparency and accountability. All policies are scored on a scale from 0 to 5, using a benchmark developed by BankTrack in cooperation with Profundo, an economic research consultancy.

To stimulate banks to make public commitment on their sustainability goals, the assessment only includes policies that are placed in the public domain and can be reviewed by the public. The report also only focuses on the commitments made in the policies itself; it does not assess banks' implementation of the policies.[3]

Close the Gap is the third study of this kind undertaken by BankTrack to stimulate the development of world-class investment policies by the banking sector. It was preceded by Shaping the future of sustainable finance in 2006 and Mind the Gap in 2007.

Jora Wolterink, responsible within BankTrack for the Close the Gap research: "The results of the report show a mixed picture. Despite the turmoil caused by the financial crisis, many banks have continued to develop more policies covering more sectors and crucial sustainability issues. Yet notwithstanding some encouraging exceptions, the overall quality of policies still leaves a lot to be desired. We hope this report encourages banks to continue this process, and to disclose more information on their policies."

Findings:

  • More banks have more publicly available policies in place. In 2007, 27% of the banks had policies in place on military industry and arms trade, with 49% in 2010. Banks have also developed more policies on power generation; from 9% in 2007 to 29% in 2010. 22% of banks developed policies on mining and oil and gas, compared to 9% in 2007. Only 6 banks out of 49 have developed no policies at all (Bangkok Bank, Bank of China, China Construction Bank, DekaBank, Industrial and Commercial Bank of China and Kasikornbank).
  • No bank has adopted policies for all sectors and issues covered in the report. WestLB (Germany) and Barclays (UK) come close, with only the issues Taxation and Operation in conflict zones not covered by their policies.
  • Most policies do not meet the criteria for what BankTrack considers an adequate, let alone a good policy; the large majority of policies received a score of only 1 point. Only in a few cases do banks meet most of the requirements for a good policy, for example HSBC for its sector policy on forests (4 points) and Rabobank's policy on Agriculture (3 points).
  • The sectors with the highest average scores are mining, oil and gas and power generation, each with an average score of 0,83. The highest score on each sector is 2; Rabobank on mining and oil and gas, West LB and Standard Chartered Bank on power generation.
  • The issue with the highest average score is indigenous peoples, with an average score of 0,94. Highest score was 2 for Morgan Stanley, JPMorganChase and Rabobank.
  • On transparency procedures, banks score an average score of 1,5. Highest score is 3 for Banco Bradesco, HSBC, ING, Intesa Sanpaolo).
  • On accountability, banks score an average score of 0,81. Highest score is 2 for Intesa Sanpaolo, Itaú Unibanco, National Australia Bank, Nedbank, RBS, Santander, Scotiabank and Westpac.
  • The bank with the highest average score for both sectors and issue policies is Rabobank, with an average score of 1,7. The bank receives the highest score in 5 sectors and 3 issues. Second best scores HSBC (1,2) followed by ING (1,16). Santander and WestLB share position four with an average score of (1,1).
  • 28 banks out of 49 banks have developed own policies on climate change, reflecting a growing awareness of banks that this is a crucial issue to tackle in their business operations. However, the quality of almost all policies is below standard, lacking for example clear commitments on phasing out financing of fossil fuel exploration and coal power plants. No bank receives a score of 2 or more, with 46 banks scoring 1 point.
  • On corruption 37 banks score 1 point. RBC, Santander and Standard Chartered Bank score best with 2 points. Not a single bank has developed specific policies on how to operate in conflict zones, which leads to a poor score for all banks. Only HSBC mentions the subject in its mining and metal policies and receives 1 point.

Johan Frijns, BankTrack coordinator, states: "There are two big gaps that banks must close: one is between what is in now in place as policies and what is required to adequately deal with sustainability issues in a specific business sector. The other gap is between having well written policies in place and then putting them into practice in such a way that they make a real difference for local communities and the environment."

------------

The research findings per sector and issue can be found here.
The final version of the Close the Gap report can be found here.

 

Notes:
[1] ABN Amro, ANZ, Banco Bradesco, Banco do Brasil, Bangkok Bank, Bank of America, Bank of China, Bank of Tokyo- Mitsubishi, Barclays, BBVA, BNP Paribas, China Construction Bank, Citi, Commonwealth Bank, Crédit Agricole, Credit Suisse, DekaBank, Deutsche Bank, Dexia, Fortis Bank Nederland, Goldman Sachs, HSBC, Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, China Industrial Bank, ING, Intesa Sanpaolo, Itaú Unibanco, JPMorgan Chase, KasikornBank (Thailand), KBC, Mizuho, Morgan Stanley, National Australia Bank, Natixis, Nedbank, Nordea, Rabobank, RBC, RBS, Santander, standard Chartered Bank, Scotiabank, Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation, Société Générale, Standard Bank, UBS, UniCredit, WestLB, Westpac.

[2] Sectors: agriculture, fishery, forestry, military industry and arms trade, mining, oil and gas, power generation. Issues: Biodiversity, climate change, corruption, human rights, indigenous peoples, labour, operation in conflict zones, taxation, toxics. Procedures: transparency, accountability.

[3] For examples of transactions that according to BankTrack do not meet adequate sustainability standards see the dodgy deal pages at the BankTrack website.

 

contact

Netherlands: Jora Wolterink, Communication officer BankTrack, T: +31 24 324922

Brazil: Roland Widmer, Amigos da Terra Amazonia Brasileira  T +55 11 3887 9369

 

United States: Nell Green, Rainforest Action Network T: +1 510-847-9777

 



ABN AMRO
ABN AMRO Bank N.V. is a Dutch state-owned bank with headquarters in Amsterdam. It was re-established, in its current form, in 2009 following the acquisition and break up…
Banco Bradesco
Banco Bradesco was established in 1943 and is one of Brazil's largest private-sector bank in Brazil and Latin-America. Its consolidated assets have a worth…
Banco do Brasil
Banco do Brasil is partly state-owned, partly publicly listed at the stock exchange in Sao Paulo. Banco do Brasil was founded by then prince-regent João VI of…
Bangkok Bank
Established in 1944, Bangkok Bank is the largest commercial bank in Thailand, one of the largest regional banks in Southeast Asia. Bangkok Bank is Thailand's market…
Bank of America
Bank of America is an American multinational banking and financial services corporation and is the second largest bank holding company in the United States by assets, and…
Bank of China
Bank of China is one of China's Big Four joint-stock commercial banks. Bank of China offers commercial banking, investment banking, insurance, asset management, aircraft…
Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFG
Bank of Tokyo - Mitsubishi UFJ is the largest bank in Japan. It was established on January 1, 2006, with the merger of the Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi, Ltd. and UFJ Bank Ltd.…
Barclays
Barclays is a major global financial services provider engaged in retail and commercial banking, credit cards, investment banking, wealth management and investment management…
BBVA
Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria (BBVA), is a multinational Spanish banking group. It was formed in 1999 from a merger of Banco Bilbao Vizcaya and Argentaria. It provides financial…
Belfius
At the end of 2011 the former Dexia Group (France/Belgium/Luxembourg) went through a major restructuring. The state of Belgium became the owner of the Dexia Bank Belgium.…
BNP Paribas
BNP Paribas is one of the main banks in Europe. It was created on 23 May 2000 through the merger of Banque Nationale de Paris (BNP) and Paribas.…
China Construction Bank
China Construction Bank (CCB) is a leading commercial bank in China providing a comprehensive range of commercial banking products and services. CCB's business consists of…
Citi
Citigroup Inc., doing business as Citi, is a major American financial services company based in New York, NY. Citigroup was formed from a merger between Citicorp and financial…
Commonwealth Bank
Commonly referred to as the Commbank, the Commonwealth Bank of Australia was founded in 1911 by the Australian government, listed on the Australian Stock Exchange in 1991,…
Crédit Agricole
The Crédit Agricole Group is a unified but decentralised group consisting of 39 Regional Banks, Crédit Agricole S.A. and many subsidiaries. It includes Crédit…
Credit Suisse
Credit Suisse Group was founded in 1856 and is headquartered in Zurich, Switzerland. It serves companies, institutional clients and high-net-worth private clients worldwide,…
Deutsche Bank
Deutsche Bank was founded in 1870 and is a leading global investment bank. It has operations throughout the world and has a strong presence in Germany and Europe. The bank´s…
Goldman Sachs
Goldman Sachs (NYSE: GS) was founded in 1869 and is a leading global financial services firm that is headquartered in New York. It provides an array of financing…
HSBC
Headquartered in London, HSBC is one of the largest banking and financial services organisations in the world. HSBC operates from around 6,100 offices in 72 countries and…
ICBC
ICBC (Industrial and Commercial Bank of China) is a joint-stock commercial bank based in the People's Republic of China.  Founded in 1984, ICBC overtook Citi to become…
Industrial Bank
The Industrial Bank was founded in 1988 and was one of the first batch of joint-stock commercial banks approved by the State Council and the People's Bank of China. The Industrial…
ING
ING (an abbreviation of Internationale Nederlanden Groep) is a Netherlands based international financial services company and one of the world's largest savings banks. ING…
Intesa Sanpaolo
Intesa Sanpaolo is a banking group resulting from the merger at January 1, 2007 between Banca Intesa and Sanpaolo IMI. It has a strong international presence focused on Central-Eastern…
Itaú-Unibanco
Banco Itau took over Unibanco at November 3, 2008 to form Itaú Unibanco Holding S.A. Itaú Unibanco is a publicly-held company which, together with…
JP Morgan Chase
JPMorgan Chase is one of the Big Four Banks of the United States (along with Bank of America, Citigroup and Wells Fargo). The firm was formed in…
Kasikorn Bank
Kasikorn Bank, otherwise known as the Thai Farmers Bank, is the fourth largest bank in Thailand. Amongst Thailand’s commercial banks, Kasikorn Bank is a market-leader…
KBC
KBC, established in 1998 from a merger between two Belgian banks (the Kredietbank and CERA Bank) and the Belgian insurance company ABB, is an integrated bancassurance group,…
Mizuho
Mizuho Financial Group is one of three Japanese "megabanks" (along with Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group and Sumitomo Mitsui Financial Group). The name "Mizuho" is an…
Morgan Stanley
Morgan Stanley was one of the four investment banks that for decades ruled on Wall Street (with Lehman Brothers, Merril Lynch and JPMorgan Chase). The corporation, founded…
NAB
National Australia Bank Group is one of the four biggest banks of Australia. The Group is structured around regional banking and wealth management operations and an international…
Natixis
Natixis is a French corporate and investment bank created in 2006 from the merger of the asset management and investment banking operations of Natexis Banque Populaire…
Nedbank
Nedbank Group Limited (‘Nedbank Group’) is a bank holding company that operates as one of the four largest banking groups in South Africa, with Nedbank Limited…
Nordea
The Nordea Group was established in 2000 but derives its origin from banks and insurance companies from the Nordic region from the early 19th century. Since 3 December…
Rabobank
Rabobank Group is a full-range financial services provider based in the Netherlands. It is founded on cooperative principles and as such owned by its members. The bank offers…
RBC
The Royal Bank of Canada (in French, Banque Royale du Canada, and commonly RBC in either language) is the largest financial institution in…
RBS
RBS was founded in 1727 and is one of the major UK banks. RBS has 40 million customers using the financial services of over 30 brands, including NatWest, Direct Line, Churchill,…
Santander
Grupo Santander is a banking group centered on BancoSantander, the largest bank in the euro area, which originated in Santander,Cantabria, Spain. Santander focuses activities…
Scotiabank
The Bank of Nova Scotia (commonly called Scotiabank in English and Banque Scotia in French) is the third largest bank in Canada by…
Société Générale
Société Générale ("SocGen") is one of the oldest banks in France, dating back to 1864. The original name was Société…
Standard Bank
Standard Bank is a South African-based financial services group with a global presence focused on emerging markets. It operates in 30 countries around the world, including…
Standard Chartered
Despite its British base, Standard Chartered has few customers in the United Kingdom and 90% of its profits come from Asia, Africa, and the Middle East. Its operations lie…
Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation
Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation is a subsidiary of the Sumitomo Mitsui Group. It is the second largest bank of Japan and also holds branches in the United States,…
UBS
Modern UBS was formed through a merger of the Union Bank of Switzerland and the Swiss Bank Corporation in June 1998.  UBS is headquartered in Zurich and Basel and it…
Westpac
Westpac is an Australian bank with a strategic focus on Australia, New Zealand and the near Pacific. The Westpac Group provides a broad range of banking and financial services,…
Login

Good login. Redirecting to
'My Banktrack'.
Wrong login. Click here to request your password.
An email has been sent with your login!
Request password
This email is unknown.
<< Back
Search
Please provide one or more search terms

Join our mailinglist

Get all our latest news releases delivered straight to your inbox - or get our News Digest once a month

banktrack tweets
RT @EC_magazine: @BankTrack our new campaign: Your guide to personal #carbondivestment https://t.co/Is2DlFkvtS
Jul 25, 2016
contact
route
Vismarkt 15
6511 VJ Nijmegen
Netherlands


contact@banktrack.org
Contact us