Banks| Policies| Dodgy Deals| Campaigns
About us| Blog| Publications| Successes| Contact us| Donate
About BankTrack
Visit us
Organisation
Our team
Our board
Guiding principles
Team up with us
Join our Active Allies list
Jobs at BankTrack
Our annual reports
Funding and finances
History
BankTrack in the media
Our privacy policy
Donate
2022-05-19 00:00:00
BNP Paribas and Société Générale: stop financing climate destruction and human rights abuses
2022-05-04 00:00:00
Barclays is big on beef and burning
2022-05-04 00:00:00
Standard Chartered’s 2022 AGM dominated by shareholder alarm over fossil financing
2022-05-02 00:00:00
Banco Santander takes a step on big oil, but what about big meat?
2022-05-20 15:14:47
Seven financiers abandon TotalEnergies' EACOP pipeline in a week
2021-12-16 13:33:02
Cambo oil field "paused" following pressure on Shell & banks
2021-12-16 13:04:42
Equator Principles improve transparency after BankTrack shows the way
2021-11-02 11:03:26
ANZ launches human rights grievance mechanism in a first for the global banking sector
Connect
2022-04-05 00:00:00
The BankTrack Human Rights Benchmark Asia
2022-03-30 00:00:00
Banking on Climate Chaos 2022
2022-03-08 00:00:00
BankTrack Annual Report 2021
2022-03-03 00:00:00
Locked out of a Just Transition: fossil fuel financing in Africa
2021-12-14 00:00:00
Actions speak louder: Assessing bank responses to human rights violations
2021-10-26 00:00:00
Equator Compliant Climate Destruction: How banks finance fossil fuels under the Equator Principles
See all publications
Browse
Home
Banks
Policies
Dodgy Deals
Campaigns
About
About BankTrack
Donate
Contact BankTrack
Publications
Victories
Follow Us
News
BankTrack blog
Facebook
Twitter Fossil Banks No Thanks Twitter Fossil Banks No Thanks Instagram
Affiliate Websites
Fossil Banks No Thanks
StopEACOP
Forests & Finance
Banks & Biodiversity
Drop JBS
Bank of Coal
Don't Buy into Occupation
Home › Blog
IEEFA: Deutsche Bank claims responsible climate leadership while bankrolling yet more thermal coal
Funds facilitated by Deutsche Bank will enable Whitehaven Coal to continue building greenfield coal mining capacity
Start
Banks

By: Tim Buckley - IEEFA
2021-12-16

Share this page:

Aerial view of the Tarrawonga coal mine (owned by Whitehaven Coal) adjacent to the Leard State Forest. Photo: Leard State Forest via Flickr (CC BY 2.0)
Go to:
Start
Related Banks

A major highlight of the COP26 summit was the UN-sponsored Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero Emissions reaching 450 globally significant firms that collectively manage US$ 130 trillion of financial assets, including Deutsche Bank.

This pledge comes with a Commitment Statement to align activities with limiting global warming to 1.5°C, an interim 2030 target, prioritising areas where banks can have the most significant impact and consistency with Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi).

The International Energy Agency (IEA) says that under a 1.5°C alignment the world can’t afford any new coal, oil or gas developments globally, with immediate effect. That much is straightforward and clear.

However, it seems that someone forgot to inform Deutsche Bank that a pledge signed off by the board is meant to be credibly implemented in good faith, and consistent with the bank’s fiduciary duties to manage key financial risks.

It was recently reported that Deutsche Bank organised a non-deal roadshow for the bonds market in preparation for new debt raising by Whitehaven Coal. The report also mentioned Deutsche Bank’s intention to act as a bookrunner for any bond issue that emerges.

Deutsche Bank has long trumpeted its climate credentials, emphasising its leadership in signing the Paris Pledge for Action back in December 2015. Yet Whitehaven Coal plans to build three new coal mines and extensions, which have no place in a 1.5°C aligned world. This is a clear contradiction of Deutsche Bank’s own Environmental and Social Policy Framework of July 2020 which says the bank “will not provide any financing for greenfield thermal coal mining” and is committed to “phase out coal exposure by 2025 worldwide”.

Whitehaven Coal used its existing credit facility to finance new coal expansions including the Maules Creek coal mine. In addition to its strong current free operating cash flow, Whitehaven is likely to need funding support for its new projects. Whitehaven has said it is looking to bond markets to replace “almost dollar for dollar” the $1 billion revolving loan from Australian and Asian banks that expires in July 2023. Any funds underwritten or facilitated by Deutsche Bank will directly enable Whitehaven Coal’s planned expansions.

In March 2018, Deutsche Bank updated and clarified its coal policy, saying: “We will not finance new greenfield coal-related infrastructure, regardless if the infrastructure is related to a new or existing plant. In addition to this commitment, we will review our coal power exposure, and for all clients depending more than 50% on coal – be it energy capacity or energy output – we will subject the provision of financial services to the availability of credible diversification plans.” There was an exception for developing markets in Asia until 2022, but Australia doesn’t fit that bill. And this policy includes both lending and capital markets.

Does Whitehaven Coal have a credible diversification plan?

For more than a decade, Whitehaven Coal has been telling its investors of plans to diversify away from its thermal coal positioning into higher value coking coal, which is supposedly less exposed to climate risk. However, for a decade this claim has rung hollow. Coking coal (also referred to as metallurgical coal) was reported by Whitehaven last month to have hit a near record low share of its total output: “Metallurgical sales represented 11% of sales for the September quarter (2021).”

Whitehaven Coal reported that 100% of its revenues were derived from coal mining sales in the September 2021 quarter. Whitehaven Coal also reported that it has three major capital developments under way, two of which are new developments, despite the corporate naming:

  1. Narrabri Underground Mine Stage 3 Extension Project
  2. Vickery Extension Project
  3. Winchester South Coal Project, a thermal and coking coal mine proposal

The A$7 00m Vickery thermal coal mine development is a proposed new development in New South Wales (NSW) of up to 10 million tonnes per annum. The site last produced coal back in 1998, more than two decades ago. So for all intents and purposes, this is an entirely new product development proposal.

Whitehaven Coal has long said this new Vickery coal mine development would be partly minority equity funded by its developed Asia coal-power utility clients in South Korea and Japan. Instead, the market has seen a steady stream of Japanese and Korean corporate divestments from thermal coal mining (for those who could find a still willing and able buyer). This has included coal exits by Sumitomo Corp, Mitsubishi Materials, Sojitz, Itochu, Mitsubishi, Mitsui & Co, Marubeni Corp and KEPCO. This follows the progressive coal mining exit by most global mining majors, including BHP, Rio Tinto and Anglo American.

Whitehaven’s entirely greenfield Winchester South thermal and coking coal mine proposal might provide a diversification into another high emissions fossil fuel area, i.e., coal for steel production. IEEFA notes for all Whitehaven’s bullish forecasts of strong growth ahead, Chinese steel production might have unexpectedly peaked back in 2020, with a decline in 2021 and potentially extending into 2022 and likely beyond, with demand declining, scrap recycling and green hydrogen/electric arc furnaces accelerating. The IEA models coking coal demand declining more than 60% globally by 2050 as (and if) the world aligns to 1.5°C.

As a result of Deutsche Bank’s greenwashing, its shares are listed in the leading sustainability indices, including the Dow Jones Sustainability World Index, the Dow Jones STOXX Sustainability Index and the FTSE4Good Index. Maybe it is time to urge sustainability index providers to do credible due diligence into whether the actions of the likes of Deutsche Bank actually support the rhetoric.

We note that the U.S. Department of the Treasury recently released its Financial Stability Oversight Council report that “Identifies Climate Change as an Emerging and Increasing Threat to Financial Stability”. Working with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the U.S. Treasury has announced it will work to prevent investor deception from climate greenwashing – a new risk for Deutsche Bank?

Arranging new debt finance for a pure-play coal mining company with no transition plan does not in any way align with a credible path to net-zero emissions. Deutsche Bank continues to use its global financial market power to raise capital for coal mining firms like Whitehaven Coal and facilitate yet more greenfield coal mining developments, entirely exposing its climate hypocrisy. Interesting to contrast this with HSBC’s new coal exit policy this week, which commits to drop existing clients who undertake new coal developments.

Investment and policy leadership is required most from the developed economies – such as Germany and Australia – which are responsible for the majority of historical carbon emissions and also prospered most from them.

It is well overdue time for Deutsche Bank to walk the talk.

From www.IEEFA.org. By Tim Buckley, Director Energy Finance Studies Australasia, Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA). 

Go to:
Start
Related Banks

Related banks

Deutsche Bank Germany

active
Browse
Home
Banks
Policies
Dodgy Deals
Campaigns
About
About BankTrack
Donate
Contact BankTrack
Publications
Victories
Follow Us
News
BankTrack blog
Facebook
Twitter Fossil Banks No Thanks Twitter Fossil Banks No Thanks Instagram
Affiliate Websites
Fossil Banks No Thanks
StopEACOP
Forests & Finance
Banks & Biodiversity
Drop JBS
Bank of Coal
Don't Buy into Occupation
Vismarkt 15
6511 VJ Nijmegen
The Netherlands

Tel: +31 24 324 9220
Contact@banktrack.org
©2016 BankTrack                Webdesign by BankTrack and EASYmind
BankTrack is a registered charity in the Netherlands (ANBI) - RSIN 813874658
Find our privacy policy here

Stay up to date

Sign up now for all BankTrack's news


Make a comment

Your comment will be reviewed, before being posted