Banks| Policies| Dodgy Deals| Campaigns
About us| Blog| Publications| Successes| Contact us| Donate
About BankTrack
Visit us
Organisation
Our team
Our board
Guiding principles
Team up with us
Jobs at BankTrack
Our annual reports
Funding and finances
History
BankTrack in the media
Our privacy policy
Donate
2023-01-23 00:00:00
Berta Cáceres: new rules for banks could help stop defender killings
2023-01-16 00:00:00
In the balance: Why European due diligence legislation must cover financial services
2022-12-08 00:00:00
Exposed: Western banks funding Qatar’s carbon bombs
2022-12-08 00:00:00
Right-wing attack on sustainable finance is the latest form of climate denial
2022-12-14 11:08:26
HSBC announces it will no longer finance new oil and gas fields
2022-10-13 15:56:39
More major banks and insurers refuse to support EACOP
2022-09-16 10:38:48
European Parliament passes emergency resolution against human rights violations & environmental threats linked to EACOP
2022-06-27 09:49:16
Crédit Agricole takes first step to phase out from the oil and gas sector
Connect
2022-11-22 00:00:00
Banking on Thin Ice: Two years in the heat
2022-11-17 00:00:00
BankTrack Global Human Rights Benchmark 2022
2022-10-21 00:00:00
Burning forests in the name of clean energy? How banks are failing to exclude the harmful wood biomass industry from finance
2022-06-28 00:00:00
The East African Crude Oil Pipeline (EACOP): Finance Risk Update No. 3
2022-04-05 00:00:00
The BankTrack Human Rights Benchmark Asia
2022-03-30 00:00:00
Banking on Climate Chaos 2022
See all publications
Browse
Home
Banks
Policies
Dodgy Deals
Campaigns
About
About BankTrack
Donate
Contact BankTrack
Publications
Victories
Follow Us
News
BankTrack blog
Facebook
Twitter Fossil Banks No Thanks Twitter Fossil Banks No Thanks Instagram
Affiliate Websites
Fossil Banks No Thanks
StopEACOP
Forests & Finance
Banks & Biodiversity
Drop JBS
Bank of Coal
Don't Buy into Occupation
Home › News
Swiss NCP misses the mark on UBS links to mass surveillance of Uighurs
UBS listed as owner of Hikvision shares it buys for its clients, yet Swiss NCP says no business relationship exists
Start
Banks

By: BankTrack & OECD Watch
2021-03-03

Contact:

Ryan Brightwell, BankTrack 

Joseph Wilde-Ramsing, OECD Watch


Share this page:

Uighur protest outside the White House in 2009. Photo: Malcolm Brown / Flickr
Go to:
Start
Related Banks

On January 28th the Swiss National Contact Point (NCP) for the OECD Guidelines accepted the specific instance filed by the Society for Threatened Peoples (STP) against Swiss Bank UBS related to the bank’s business relationship with Hikvision, a company that is aiding China’s mass surveillance and genocide of  Uighurs. This is the first OECD NCP complaint to focus on a financial institution’s asset management business and passive products. Up until now, the NCP procedure has focused on asset owners’ direct shareholding or banks’ mainstream lending.

In its assessment, the Swiss NCP concluded that “a direct link between UBS’s products and services and the alleged human rights violations could not be excluded”. The Swiss acceptance of the case is significant because it represents the first time an NCP has recognized the responsibility banks have for their passive investments through indexed funds.  In recent years, the asset management industry has seen a significant shift towards passive investment strategies, by which funds are typically invested in an index rather than in actively traded shares. Currently, over USD 10 trillion is invested in passively managed funds globally, so the recognition of banks’ responsibility for addressing impacts caused by these investments is important.

However, on a second element of the complaint, the Swiss NCP concluded that no business relationship between UBS and Hikvision exists in relation to UBS’s role as custodian for Hikvision shares on behalf of clients. This is despite UBS holding the title of the Hikvision shares, being listed publicly as the owner, and allowing its client (the ‘beneficial owner’ of the shares) to invest in the company in secret. According to research by the STP, UBS has maintained a business relationship with Hikvision since 2016. The bank is involved in the technology company through investment products and services as well as manages shares in the name of unknown investors as a “nominee shareholder”.

However, in regard to UBS acting as a nominee shareholder of shares in Hikvision, the NCP stated: “Based on the information received from UBS, the Swiss NCP concludes that UBS is not an investor in Hikvision but acts as a custodian of Hikvision shares on behalf of its clients and does not actively advise clients to buy Hikvision shares. The mere management of clients’ shares as a custodian implies a business relationship between the bank and its clients, but not with Hikvision.”

Worrying misinterpretation

This decision represents a worrying misinterpretation of the spirit of the OECD Guidelines and the UN Guiding Principles, which contain an expansive definition of business relationships: “Business relationships refer to those relationships a business enterprise has with business partners, entities in its value chain and any other non-State or State entity directly linked to its business operations, products or services.” The expansive definition of business relationships is intended to increase the scope of an enterprise’s responsibility beyond its own operations and activities to its value chains as well. In this case, UBS provides a service that is an essential part of the investment value chain, allowing the bank’s clients to invest in Hikvision.

In acting as custodian or nominee shareholder, UBS holds the title to the Hikvision shares and is listed as the owner in Hikvision’s own annual reports. Its client, the beneficial owner of the shares, remains invisible. As such, UBS is not only helping its clients to invest in Hikvision but also helping them to do so anonymously. The fact that the bank enables its client to hold these shares in secret – in this case, in a company that is aiding mass surveillance of China’s Uighurs, including in detention camps, in what has been described as genocide – adds an additional layer of importance to what UBS does. This is a valuable service for clients, who otherwise may not dare to make those investments.

Furthermore, the Swiss NCP’s decision does not sufficiently account for specific Chinese market conditions which mean that the only way a foreign investor or shareholder can invest in Chinese companies is via an index fund or a depositary bank. Services such as the holding of nominee shareholdings are therefore a basic prerequisite for market access in China.

Perverse incentives

For the Swiss NCP to imply that UBS has no responsibility in this regard is deeply problematic. It creates a massive, and easy, escape route for investors to avoid application of the OECD Guidelines. It clearly sets up perverse incentives whereby more investors might choose to reorganise their shareholdings this way, making it impossible for stakeholders and rightsholders to identify who they should actually be targeting when seeking to address adverse impacts and those responsible for them. More banks might offer these services essentially as a way to screen out linkage and avoid taking any responsibility despite their crucial role in the value chain.

OECD Watch and BankTrack call on the OECD to clarify the issue of business relationships in the situation of nominee shareholders and urge the Swiss NCP to reconsider its position in light of the spirit of the OECD Guidelines and UNGPs.

Go to:
Start
Related Banks

Related banks

UBS Switzerland

active
Browse
Home
Banks
Policies
Dodgy Deals
Campaigns
About
About BankTrack
Donate
Contact BankTrack
Publications
Victories
Follow Us
News
BankTrack blog
Facebook
Twitter Fossil Banks No Thanks Twitter Fossil Banks No Thanks Instagram
Affiliate Websites
Fossil Banks No Thanks
StopEACOP
Forests & Finance
Banks & Biodiversity
Drop JBS
Bank of Coal
Don't Buy into Occupation
Vismarkt 15
6511 VJ Nijmegen
The Netherlands

Tel: +31 24 324 9220
Contact@banktrack.org
©2016 BankTrack                Webdesign by BankTrack and EASYmind
BankTrack is a registered charity in the Netherlands (ANBI) - RSIN 813874658
Find our privacy policy here

Stay up to date

Sign up now for all BankTrack's news


Make a comment

Your comment will be reviewed, before being posted