english
français
español
中国版
issues
sectors
Agriculture
Fisheries
Forestry, Pulp and Paper
Military industry and arms trade
Mining
Oil and gas
Power generation
Transparency
Accountability
|
banks
loading...
focus
loading...
members
loading...
dodgy deals
loading...
companies
loading...
further resources
documents
dodgy deals
companies
Power generation Nuclear power plant in Mochovce, Slowakia (source: BankTrack)
what is at stake
- Go to what is at stake in coal, dams and nuclear energy sectors- The world's primary energy demand for electricity generation is growing rapidly. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), future energy demand is projected to increase by 45% in the period 2006-2030. A large part of this growth is expected to come from the power sector. In order to meet these projected demands, annual investment in the power sector will need to rise to US$ 520 billion in the period 2007-2030. In a severely carbon constrained world, it is impossible to meet this energy demand through conventional, fossil-fuel based sources. There is growing political and social pressure to meet future energy demands predominantly through sustainable energy sources such as wind and solar power. Such a rapid shift requires massive investments in renewable power generation capacity. A recent United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) report estimates yearly investment needs in sustainable energy up of US$ 500 billion in 2020. Companies within the electricity market therefore face a huge challenge; securing the supply of reliable and affordable energy while organising a rapid transformation to a environmentally sustainable energy supply system. Energy production based on conventional sources has a number of negative social and environmental impacts: -readmore- Coal Coal is the cheapest fossil fuel available in many markets, abundantly available throughout the world. It is also the most polluting energy resource and the dominant source of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions. In addition, the entire production process, from coal mining to combustion, severely disrupts ecosystems and contaminates water supplies by emitting other greenhouse gases like nitrogen oxide and methane, and toxic chemicals like mercury and arsenic. There is a staggering price attached to the use of coal, paid for by the environment, people's health and by communities adjacent to coal mines. Lately, the coal industry has made efforts to rebrand itself as producers of ‘clean coal', citing the development of improved coal power plants and the use of Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) techniques. CCS is an unproven approach to mitigating the global warming effects of fossil fuel-based electricity generation by capturing CO2 at its source and storing it underground in (presumably) stable geological formations or underwater. Even with the best currently available technologies, CCS would consume a huge amount of extra energy and would increase the fuel needs of a coal-fired power plant by 25-40%. In addition, investment in CCS does nothing to further the development of truly renewable and sustainable energy technologies or energy efficiency that are needed for "real" sustainability. Dams Large dams and associated infrastructure are among the most controversial and potentially destructive of all internationally-financed projects. According to the World Commission on Dams (WCD) large dams have displaced between 40 and 80 million people worldwide. Millions more have been ousted by the construction of canals, powerhouses and other associated infrastructure. Many of these people have not been satisfactorily resettled, nor have they received adequate compensation, and those who have been resettled have rarely had their livelihoods restored. Furthermore, hydroelectric dams and high-voltage transmission lines are often located in ecologically sensitive areas, Dams have fragmented and stilled 60% of the world's rivers, leading to profound and often irreversible impacts on riverine and adjoining terrestrial environments. Meanwhile, the economic benefits of large dams have often been elusive. Large dams tend to under-perform their targets for power generation, and lengthy construction delays and large cost overruns are routine. Nuclear energy Nuclear energy is often presented as a clean source of electricity, as the CO2 emissions from this process are lower than from fossil fuels combustion. However, contamination and nuclear waste resulting from nuclear power generation carries serious health and environmental hazards. Moreover, uranium fuel is produced through mining and processing techniques which are highly polluting and energy consuming. In addition, because the supply of uranium is limited (estimated resources would feed current level of consumption for about 100 years, nuclear energy is not considered a sustainable investment. Nuclear energy use also raises major safety concerns. Nuclear power plants contain various forms of radioactive pollution that could significantly impact a large amount of countries and communities (for many years) in case of an accident. There are additional concerns that nuclear power plants might present attractive targets for terrorists. In addition, both nuclear energy technologies and materials used for electricity generation could be diverted to nuclear weapons. The Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons gives every country the right to employ nuclear technology for peaceful activities. Nonetheless, risks are high that this technology could be used for military purposes, especially in less stable countries. selected standards and initiatives
For the reasons explained on the issue page of climate change, investments in coal-fired power plants, CCS and nuclear power are considered investments in non-renewable fuel sources. Banks should therefore exclude these fuel sources from their investment portfolios. With respect to dams and associated infrastructure, the most authoritative and broadly supported sets of standards are the guidelines articulated by the WCD. The core of the WCD recommendations was its "rights and risks" approach to project decision-making, and its seven strategic priorities and supporting principles: -readmore- Gaining Public Acceptance: Public acceptance of key decisions should be ensured for equitable and sustainable water and energy resources development. Where projects affect indigenous and tribal peoples, such processes are guided by their free, prior and informed consent. Comprehensive Options Assessment: Alternatives to dams should be subject of a comprehensive and participatory assessment of the full range of policy, institutional and technical options, in which social and environmental aspects have the same significance as economic and financial factors. Addressing Existing Dams: Opportunities should be taken to optimise benefits from existing dams, address outstanding social issues and strengthen environmental mitigation and restoration measures. Sustaining Rivers and Livelihoods: Options assessment and decision-making around river development should prioritise the avoidance of impacts, followed by the minimisation and mitigation of harm to the health and integrity of the river system. Avoiding impacts through good site selection and project design is a priority. Recognising Entitlements and Sharing Benefits: Mutually agreed and legally enforceable mitigation and development provisions need to be negotiated with adversely affected people. Accountability of responsible parties to agreed mitigation, resettlement and development provisions is ensured through legal means, such as contracts, and through accessible legal recourse at the national and international level. Ensuring Compliance: Compliance with applicable regulations, criteria and guidelines, and project-specific negotiated agreements needs to be secured at all critical stages in project planning and implementation. Regulatory and compliance frameworks use incentives and sanctions to ensure effectiveness where flexibility is needed to accommodate changing circumstances. Sharing rivers for Peace, Development and Security: The use and management of resources should be the subject of agreement between states to promote mutual self-interest for regional cooperation and peaceful collaboration. Dams on shared rivers should not be built where riparian states raise objections that are upheld by international panels. content of a bank policy
Banks should adopt a policy for investing in companies in the electricity generation sector that is aimed at phasing out support for fossil fuel and uranium based power generation, and that expands support for renewable sources and environmentally sound innovation. The following elements should be incorporated in a bank's electricity generation policy: essential elements
The bank will not invest in companies that:
Furthermore, the bank will only invest in:
The bank also includes in its policy that it is actively pursuing a shift in its electricity generation portfolio, away from fossil fuel and uranium, towards renewable energy sources. additional elements
The bank will not invest in
Furthermore, the bank will only invest in:
Banks should either develop an integrated policy giving sufficient attention to the specific characteristics of electricity generation, or choose to develop separate policies as long as the content of these policies is consistent on overarching issues, includes the content described in other paragraphs and holds at least the elements listed above.
scores
how do we score this?
The bank:
analysis scores power generation
The majority of the banks scores one point on
this sector, mainly because they are signatories to the Equator Principles or the
Carbon Principles. In last years, more banks have developed their own policy on
power generation. Often the scope of a policy is limited, covering only nuclear
energy, coal fired power generation or dams and infrastructure.
The three banks that are accredited two points, HSBC, Standard Chartered Bank and WestLB, do not exclude nuclear and/or coal fired power generation but do require the World Commission on Dams' recommendations. Ten banks have neither developed a policy nor signed the Equator Principle or the Carbon Principles.
|
Loading